CULTURAL
KEYLINE
The Life Work of Dr. Neville
Yeomans
Thesis
submitted
24 December 2005
For
the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy
In
the
Photo
1 Four stages in Dr. Neville Yeoman’s life
Top
left: At Fraser
House, circa 1961
(Yeomans, N. 1965a, p. 81)
Top
Right: As election
candidate, 1969
(Yeomans,
N. 1965a)
Bottom
Left: Wedding to Lien,
November 1972
From
Lien Yeoman’s book – used with permission
(Yeomans
and Yeomans 2001)
Bottom
Right: On Atherton
Tablelands, 1993 Yeomans Family photo
-
used with permission
Two Poems Written by Dr. Neville Yeomans
Together
the following poems (Yeomans
2000a; Yeomans 2000b)
provide a feel for the subject matter of this thesis. I first knew of the
existence of these two poems when they were handed out at Neville Yeomans’
funeral on 7 June 2000.
The Inma
There
seems to be a new spirituality going around - or a philosophy – or is it an
ethical and moral movement, or a feeling?
Anyway,
this Inma religion or whatever it is – what does it believe in?
It
believes in the coming-together, the inflow of alternative human energy, from
all over the world.
It
believes in an ingathering and a nexus of human persons’ values, feelings,
ideas and actions.
Inma
believes in the creativity of this gathering together and this connexion of
persons and values.
It
believes that these values are spiritual,
moral and ethical, as well as humane, beautiful, loving and happy.
Inma
believes that persons may come and go as they wish, but also it believes that
the values will stay and fertilize its area, and it believes the nexus will
cover the globe.
Inma
believes that Earth loves us and that we love Earth.
It
believes that from the love and from the creativity will come a new model for
the world of human future.
It
believes that we have started that future - now.
I
guess that if you and I believe these things we are Inma.
On Where
Perhaps
somewhere there is an unimportant place caught
between East and West, North and South, past and future.
It
is so far behind that it can only go forward.
Its
Indigenous people are so badly treated they will risk anything for a better
life.
Its
white overlords are so distant from the centre of their
own culture that they don’t know where to go except to
self-government.
It
is wealthy, industrial, consumer, under-populated and chaotic.
It has
tropical coasts and islands. It has cool mountains and tablelands.
It
is closer to Asian and Melanesian peoples than its own capital city, and it
often sees itself as the end of the earth.
Yet
the desires of some of its citizens are:
to
build the first free territory guided by global humane laws
to
implement the UN covenants on Human Rights
to
give migrants, visitors and native born an equal say
to
accept ideas, people and music of living from all over
to
welcome and respect every interested person
to
love Planet Earth, and
to
take a next step towards a happier more beautiful more human community.
Maybe
one such place is called Northern Queensland,
But
an Aboriginal word meaning 'a coming together' is Inma.
CONTENTS
Acknowledging
Abstract
CHAPTER ONE – ON HUMAN
FUTURES
The Thesis Structure
Three Interconnected Foci
On Global Reform
Keyline and Cultural Keyline
Research Questions
Life Changes
A Warm December Morning
Summary
CHAPTER TWO - NEVILLE’S
MODEL FOR A 250-YEAR TRANSITION TO A HUMANE CARING EPOCH
Introduction
A New Cultural Synthesis
Webs and Lacewebs
Summary
CHAPTER THREE – THE
EMERGENCE OF THERAPEUTIC COMMUNITIES AND COMMUNITY MENTAL HEALTH -
History, Types and Significance
Overview
The Emergence of Popular/Folk and Scientific Models
Nineteen and Twentieth Century Practice
Early Australian Experience
Evolving Therapeutic Communities
Social Psychiatry, Social Therapy and Milieu Therapy
Decline of Therapeutic Committees in the
Decline of Therapeutic Committees in the
Wider Applications of Therapeutic Community
Rehabilitation Services, Transitional Facilities and
The Move to Community Based Care
Community Mental Health - The
Community Mental Health in the
Community Mental Health in
Self-Help and Mutual Aid Groups
Organizations, Networks and Mutual Help Providing
Support and Sustenance to Marginal People
Healthy Living Centres
Everyday Life Mutual Help
Natural Nurturers in Everyday Life
Possible Futures
Shifts In Psychiatric Models
The Psychosocial Model, Therapeutic Governance and
Global Social Control
Summary
CHAPTER FOUR – ON METHOD
Overview
On Being an Insider Looking in
Explicating the Inexplicable
Data Collecting
Note Taking
Interviewing
Interviewing Neville
Interviews With Bruen and Chilmaid
Margaret Cockett and Other Interviewees
Prolonged On-Site Social Action Research
Archival Research
Engaging in Naturalistic Inquiry
Ensuring Trustworthiness
My Theoretical Perspectives
Using Emergent Design
Writing Through and Making Sense
Writing Through
Using Grounded Theory
Recognising Fractals and Holographs
Using Thick Description
Using Thematic Analysis/Narrative Analysis
Using Connoisseurship
Structure/Event Process Analysis
Emergence of Intuition
On Being a Scientific Detective
Crafting the Writing
Summary
CHAPTER FIVE - CONNECTING
SUSTAINABLE AGRICULTURE AND PSYCHOSOCIAL TRANSITION
Orienting
Inspiring Trauma
Water Telling Us What to do With it
Keyline Emerges
Creating Deep Soil Fast
Designing Farms
Links Between Sustainable Agriculture, Psychosocial
Change And Indigenous Sociomedicine
Tikopia - Celebrating Difference to Maintain Unity
And Wellbeing
Other Influences
Melding the Precursors
Summary
CHAPTER SIX - FRASER HOUSE
MILIEU
Orientating
Introducing Fraser House
Window of
Layout, Locality, and Cultural Locality
Assuming a Social Basis of Mental Illness
Locality as Connexion to Place
Cultural Locality
Sourcing Patients
Back Wards and Prisons
Aboriginal and Islander Patients
Family- Friends-Workmate Network as Focus of Change
Balancing Community
Being Voluntary
Re-Casting the System
Fraser House as Therapeutic Community
Staff Relating
For and Against
The Use of Slogans
Fraser House Wellness Norms
Handbooks on Fraser House Structure and Process
Family Therapy
Drug Use
Summary
CHAPTER
SEVEN - GOVERNANCE AND OTHER RECONSTITUTING PROCESSES
The Resocializing Program – Using Governance Therapy
Committees and Balancing Governance
Patient Administration
The New Role for all Staff
Flexible Rigidity
Patient Treatment and Training
Fraser House Training
The Canteen and the Little Red Van
The Domiciliary Care Committee and Domiciliary Care
Crisis Support
The Outpatients, Relatives and Friends Committee
Constituting Rules and Constitutions
Summary
CHAPTER EIGHT – FRASER HOUSE
BIG MEETING
Big Group - Using Collective Social Forces
Preventing Session Creep
Big Group Layout
A Mood That Attunes
On Neville’s Role as Leader and his Group Processes
On The Side of Constructive Striving
Neville’s Sensory Functioning
The Far-From-Equilibrium Learning Organization
Gain, Loss, Threat and Frustration
Summary
CHAPTER NINE – FRASER HOUSE
TRANSITIONARY PROCESSES
Introduction
Social Category Based Small Group Therapy
Child-Parent Playgroups
Individual Therapy
Research as Therapy
Values Research
Psychiatric Research Study Group
Work as Therapy
Margaret Mead Visits Fraser House
Cultural Keyline
Attending and Sensing
Forming Cultural Locality
Strategic Design and Context-Guided Perturbing of
the Social Topography
Leaving Nature to do the Work
Cultural Keyline in Groups
Summary
CHAPTER TEN – CRITIQUING AND
REPLICATING
Orientating
Critique of Fraser House in the Sixties
A Response
Replicating Fraser House In State Run Enclaves
-
Fraser House and Transitions to Community Self
Caring
A
Follow-Up Service and Liaison with Outside Organizations.
Catchment Areas
Neville’s Actions to Phase Out Fraser House
The Decline of Therapeutic Communities
Fraser House Evaluation
Fraser House a Model for American Research
Ethical Issues in Replicating Fraser House
Inma and Fraser House
Networking
Ex Fraser House Patients and Local Self Help Action
Findings
A Powerful Influence
Summary
CHAPTER ELEVEN - FRASER
HOUSE OUTREACH
Orientating
Extending
Advisory Roles
Coordinator of Community Mental Health Services
Community Health
Evolving Asian Links
Wellbeing Action Using Festivals, Gatherings and
Other Happenings
The
The Second Festival – The Paddington Festival
Festival Three -
Festival Four - Campbelltown Festival
Festival Five – The Aquarius Festival
Festival Six – Confest
Festival Seven – The Cooktown Arts Festival
The Keyline Trust
Divorce Law Reform
Writing Newspaper Columns
Implicitly Applying Cultural Keyline in Business and
Other Organisational Environments
Evolving Functional Matrices
On Becoming an Election Candidate
Influencing Other States
Findings
Summary
CHAPTER TWELVE - EVOLVING
THE LACEWEB
Orienting
Evolving the Laceweb
Aboriginal Human Relations Gatherings
The Self Organising Rollout for Bourke
Further Rollout for Armidale
Wider Networks
Evolving Small Therapeutic Community Houses in Far
Further Travels
Speaking on the Indigenous Platform at the UN Ngo
Rio Earth
Geoff and Norma Guest’s Aboriginal Youth Training
Farm
Developing Aboriginal and
Communities
Gathering
The
Unpo and Other Global Action
New State Movement Update
Indigenous People Linked to Confest
Cultural Healing Action
Using Ideas from the Laceweb Homepage
Summary
CHAPTER
THIRTEEN – EVOLVING THE LACEWEB SOCIAL-MOVEMENT
Orienting
Evolving the Laceweb as a Social Movement
Evolving Natural Nurturer Networks
Linking the Network into the Wider Local Community
The Enabling Network
The Sharing of Micro-Experiences Among Locals - A
Summary
On Global Reform
Three Transition Phases
Laceweb and Functional Matrices
Examples of Laceweb Action
Inma Involvement in Urban Renewal Project
Signing UN-Inma Memorandum of Understanding and
Treaties
East Asian
Summary
CHAPTER FOURTEEN - WHITHER
GOETH THE WORLD – HUMANITY OR BARBARITY?
Conclusions
Framing Values
Being in the Zone of Growth
Non-Expressible Knowingness
Creating a New Model of Human Future
Contexts for Growth
Appendices
References
Photo 2. Dr. Neville Yeomans at his desk
at Fraser House - Circa 1961 (Yeomans, N. 1965a)
This thesis researches psychiatrist barrister
Dr. Neville Yeomans’ lifetime action research into changing the social-life
world towards becoming more caring, humane and respecting of all life-forms.
Particularly, it researches Yeomans’ adapting of his father’s sustainable
agriculture Keyline processes to the human social life-world as ‘Cultural
Keyline’.
After a brief review of
therapeutic community, community mental health and self-help networks in the
UK, USA and Australia, and a brief summary of Keyline and Indigenous precursors
influencing Neville, the research focuses, firstly, on describing and analysing
the structures/processes used by Yeomans in evolving Australia’s first
psychiatric therapeutic community ‘Fraser House’ in Sydney from 1959 to 1968.
In particular, what contributions did Neville make to evolving social and
community psychiatry and clinical sociology in
Neville Yeomans’ methods of social action and
research can be traced to his collaboration with his father P.A. Yeomans (along
with brothers Allen and Ken). P.A is
recognised as the most significant person globally in the past 200 years in the
field of sustainable agriculture (Mulligan and Hill 2001). P.A. evolved Keyline sustainable
agricultural practices based around Keypoints in landform that have system
implications.
In researching Cultural Keyline,
the thesis details how its precursor, Keyline agricultural practice,
recognizes, respects, and makes use of natural forms, functions and processes
in nature - especially landform, gravity, as well as self-organizing and
emergent aspects of natural systems. The research outlines how Keyline practice
fosters nature’s tendency for thriving, and documents and analyses Neville’s
adapting of Keyline as Cultural
Keyline in fostering emergent and thriving potential in social systems. Four
non-linear interconnected inter-related aspects of Cultural Keyline are
identified:
1.
Attending
and sensing self organising, emergence and Keypoints conducive to coherence
within social contexts
2.
Forming
cultural locality (people connecting together connecting to place)
3.
Strategic,
design and emergent context-guided theme-based perturbing of the social
topography
4.
Sensing
and attending to the natural social system self-organising in response to the
perturbing, and monitoring outcomes.
In developing ‘Cultural
Keyline’, Neville adapted his father’s Keyline to the social life world.
Neville pioneered therapeutic community in
The research also traces Neville’s
use of his Cultural Keyline model in pioneering family therapy, suicide/crisis
telephone services, counselling and family therapy within family law, community
mental health (becoming the first NSW Director of Community Mental Health, and
starting Australia’s first Community Mental Health Centre), psychosocial
self-help groups and networks, multicultural festivals, cultural healing
action, mediation and mediation therapy.
The
thesis then explores Neville’s development of a number of small therapeutic
community houses in North Queensland, as well as evolving what Neville termed
an ‘International Normative Model Area’ or ‘INMA’ in northern Australia that
continues as a micro-model exploring linked local, regional and global
governance as an aspect of epochal transition. An outcome of Neville’s action research has been the
emergence of informal Laceweb networks amongst Indigenous and other
intercultural healers in the northern
I have elected to generally
use Dr. Neville Yeomans’ first name throughout this thesis as a mark of my
profound respect for him. For me he was Neville, not ‘Yeomans’.
This thesis explores
Neville’s claim that his lifelong action research was towards enabling gentle
transitions to a new humane,
caring, life-affirming global intercultural synthesis - towards epochal transition - a two
hundred and fifty to three hundred year plus project towards a more caring and
humane future. Neville’s claim was that he devoted 70 of his 73 years to this
dream. For Neville, the term
‘enabler’ simply meant ‘someone who supported others to be able’.
This thesis focuses
upon three interconnected foci of action by Neville:
Firstly, the
precursors guiding Neville and the structures/processes he used in 1959 in establishing
and evolving Australia’s first therapeutic community, ‘Fraser House’, in North
Ryde Psychiatric Hospital, Sydney.
Secondly, Neville’s
Fraser House outreaches; and
Thirdly, the history,
theory and practice leading to Neville supporting the evolving of the Laceweb
Social Movement among Indigenous and intercultural healers throughout the East
Asia Oceania Australasia Region.
The research explores
Neville’s role in evolving social action in each of the above three foci. The
thesis traces Neville’s envisaging of new forms of social realities respecting
and embracing diversity and having resonance with traditional Indigenous
relating to the web of life. One fundamental aspect of this Indigenous-based
change explored by Neville is fostering regionality (‘connecting to region’)
and locality (‘connecting to place’) in a life-world (the world of living
systems) where humans are recognizing, respecting, celebrating, fostering, and
sustaining both the inter-connectedness of humane nurturing values, and the
diversity of all life forms and networks.
To quote Neville’s poem (Yeomans
2000a):
It believes that these
values are spiritual,
moral and ethical, as well as humane, beautiful, loving and happy.
The first of the three parts of the thesis is
about the precursors influencing Neville’s pioneering in Australia of community
therapy and his global pioneering of full-family residential therapeutic
community practices within the therapeutic community based psychiatric unit,
Fraser House (Yeomans 1961a, p.
382 - 384; Yeomans 1961b, p. 829 - 830; Yeomans, Hennessy et al. 1965b). Neville set up this Unit at
In the second part of the thesis, the
research documents the spread and influence of Fraser House’s guiding frames of
reference, structure, processes and practices into the wider community. The
claims by Neville and other ex-Fraser House staff that Fraser House’s
structure, processes and practices had a substantial effect on mental health
practice in
The third part of the thesis traces the use
by Neville of Fraser House’s frames of reference, structures, processes,
practices and outreach in enabling the evolving of the Laceweb Social Movement
spreading among Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander people and other kindred
minorities in the remote regions of Far North Australia. The research documents
the psychosocial and other histories of Laceweb social action since the early
Seventies; it also traces the extending of the movement throughout the East
Asia Oceania Australasia Region and discusses the Laceweb’s role in Neville’s
epochal transition project action.
Chapter One introduces Neville’s
life work and discusses the significance of the topic, outlines the nature of
the research and the research questions, and discusses why they are important.
It also discusses briefly the story of how I became involved with this project,
and the way my biogeography has led me to undertake this research. An outline
of the rest of the thesis is included. Because of the expansiveness of the subject, some of the
matters that will be treated in some depth in this research are introduced
briefly in this first chapter. As a further background to this research,
Chapter Two introduces Neville’s macro aim of epochal change. Chapter Three
provides a very brief literature review of the development of therapeutic
community, community mental health and self-help groups in
In 1973, Neville wrote
perhaps his most significant paper called ‘On Global Reform – International
Normative Model Areas (INMA)’ (Yeomans 1974). In that paper Neville sets out his strategy and action
processes for global epochal transition. This research has used that ‘On Global
Reform’ paper as a key document in tracking down seemingly unconnected action
and in understanding and integrating together Neville’s extensive and diverse
innovative doings.
The Concise Dictionary (Hayward and Sparkes 1984) defines ‘epoch’ as ‘a stop, check or pause; a period
characterized by momentous events; an era’, and defines ‘epoch-making’ as
something ‘of such importance as to mark an epoch’. An epoch is also a turning point. An ‘epochal
transition’ is a time marking a shift between two long eras such as the epochal
shift between feudal society and industrial society in the
Dr. Neville Yeomans was born in 1928 to
Percival and Rita Yeomans and died in
Neville adapted Keyline as ‘Cultural Keyline’
and pioneered this in the fields of social psychiatry and community psychiatry,
clinical sociology, sociology of medicine, social psychology, psychobiology,
intercultural studies, future studies, peace studies, humanitarian law and
global governance. Neville discussed with me many times (December 1991,
December 1993, July, 1998, August, 1999) about how he had adapted his father’s
sustainable agriculture work into what he called ‘Cultural Keyline’. Cultural
Keyline is a core model and concept underlying Neville’s life work, and an
integrating theme in this research - a model for sustaining biopsychosocial
wellbeing in inter-relating and inter-acting with others. Neville Yeomans’
‘Cultural Keyline’ adapts Keyline to human life (psychosocial, personal,
interpersonal, communal, cultural and intercultural). The thesis details how
Keyline agricultural practice recognizes, respects, and makes use of natural
forms, functions and processes in nature, especially landform, gravity, and
self-organizing and emergent aspects of natural systems. Keyline practice
fosters nature’s tendency for thriving.
The Yeomans set out to ‘harvest’ all water
falling or flowing onto their farms. They recognised the three primary
landforms - main ridge, primary ridge and primary valley. On the main drainage
line at the head of the primary valley is a small (often a metre square) patch
of land where each of the three land forms meet. P.A. called this the Keypoint.
A Keypoint is on the fall line in the
primary valley on the contour above the first wider gap between the contours at
the higher end of the valley.
The Keypoint and the contour line through the Keypoint (called the Keyline)
have many special properties detailed in my thesis.
The Yeomans discovered many processes and
ways to design their farm - creating contexts for nature to thrive. A key
understanding is that the Yeomans set the farm up so that nature did the change
work – it was self-organising. I took
the following photo in 2001 at the spot where the Yeomans first discovered the
significance of the Keypoint.
Photo
3.
The place where the Yeomans discovered the
Keypoint – Photo I took during July 2001
The photo is the
view up towards the main ridge at the top of a primary valley with the primary
ridges down either side of the primary valley. A smaller partial ridge splits
the head of the valley above the Keypoint. The Keypoint is on the left of the
far end of the dam. The Keyline is the contour marked by the edge of the water.
As Keyline fosters emergent farm potential,
Cultural Keyline is a rich way of fostering emergent and thriving potential in
social systems. Keyline is detailed in
Chapter Five. How Neville evolved Cultural Keyline in Fraser House is introduced in Chapters Six to Eight and detailed
in Chapter Nine.
All of
Neville and his father’s work was informed and guided by a relational
familiarity with Australian Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander wisdom about
the social and natural life-worlds. While non-Aboriginal people had seen
Inma
believes that Earth loves us and that we love Earth (2000a).
‘Earth
loves us’ comes first. Neville and his father’s work and way were guided and
informed by this ancient loving caring respecting tradition.
In preparing for his
humanitarian life work, Neville obtained degrees in zoology and then medicine –
extended to psychiatry. He completed postgraduate studies in sociology and psychology,
accompanied by extensive reading in history, anthropology and peace studies. He
followed these studies with a degree in law, specializing in humanitarian law,
and law studies in mediation as an alternative to adversarial law in dispute
settlement (Carlson and Yeomans 1975). During the 1970s, he studied spoken and
written Chinese and Indonesian, as well as Chinese painting. As part of his
quest to become sensitive to the intercultural nuances of the East Asia,
Oceania, Australasia region, Neville studied the Indonesian language at a
Neville commenced his endeavours with what he
called (Dec, 1993 and July, 1998) the ‘mad and bad’ people of
Neville said (July, 1998) that he recognized
that in 1959, with considerable upheaval and questioning in the area of mental
health in NSW, and a Royal Commission being mooted into past practices, there
was a small window of opportunity for innovation. Neville started his epochal
quest in earnest by setting up the psychiatric unit, Fraser House, in the
grounds of the
The thesis researches
Neville’s role firstly, in evolving social psychiatry, community psychiatry and
clinical sociology[1] in
While the many things
Neville pioneered are now known by many in
After detailing
Fraser House structure/process and outreach, the research traces Neville
Yeomans fostering of the emergence of a social movement he called the ‘Laceweb’
evolving amongst oppressed
Indigenous/Small Minorities in the East Asia, Oceania, Australasian
Region. The research documents wellbeing
action by Indigenous/Small Minority and intercultural psychosocial healers and
natural nurturers that has been evolving informally in the Region for over 45
years.
While aspects of this
endeavour have been the subject of a PhD (Clark 1969) and other research and writings in the past (Yeomans 1961a; Yeomans 1961b; Clark and
Yeomans 1965; Yeomans, N. 1965a; Clark 1969; Clark and Yeomans 1969; Watson
1970; Paul and Lentz 1977; Yeomans 1980a; Yeomans 1980b; Wilson 1990; Clark
1993, p. 61, 117), this will be the first research that attempts to draw the
many aspects of the above and related social action research together.
It took a
number of months of reflection after discussions with Neville and my Supervisor
for three ‘natural’ parts of Neville’s epochal transition action to emerge -
Fraser House, Fraser House outreach, and the evolving of the Laceweb.
The
research questions are:
1.
What is Cultural Keyline and its precursor
Keyline? How do you make use of them? With what potential outcomes?
2.
What were the theoretical and action precursors
to Neville Yeomans evolving the therapeutic community psychiatric unit Fraser
House?
3.
What change processes, innovations and
social action evolved in and from Fraser House? How do these differ from
processes used in other psychiatric therapeutic communities? With what effect?
4.
What was Neville’s outreach from Fraser
House?
5.
What is INMA? What is the Laceweb? What
are the Laceweb’s structure and process, and how has it being evolved and
sustained?
6.
Were each of the above an aspect of
Neville’s action research on epochal transition?
7.
What patterns and integration are there
linking aspects of Neville Yeomans’ work - Fraser House, Fraser House outreach
and the Laceweb? Was Cultural Keyline used in all of the above aspects?
8.
What possible futures may emerge from
Laceweb praxis towards epochal transition?
9.
What is the significance of Neville’s life
work?
As the thesis is
investigating something with so many facets, I had to make decisions about my
research focus, and what was to be included and excluded. I have elected to
report extensively on structure, process and their interconnectedness while
providing a broad feel for their fit in the mediums and interstices of
Neville’s massive endeavour. In order to cope with the extent and complex
richness of my focal interests, the following are excluded.
Firstly, while outlining and
answering the criticisms others have made about Neville and Fraser House, I do
not engage in identifying shortcomings, or criticizing his life work. I have gathered
together material that others may use for further research, critique, and
evaluation. The limits I set to my research have still left me with a massive
endeavour.
Secondly, I report on
Neville’s extensive life work and public persona and the public life of Fraser
House staff. I exclude research concerning his personal life while
acknowledging and recognizing this was, and is fundamental to an understanding
of the man. In fact, Neville recognized and made restricted file notes on
issues in his and other Fraser House senior staff’s private lives that were
reflected in the dynamics of Fraser House. Neville drew attention to the
ethical dilemmas involved in research where adequate writing up of a case would
give sufficient material to identify focal people to their potential harm. (In
some contexts confidentiality should be paramount.) Neville made suggestions in
a short monograph to the World Health Organization that may address these
dilemmas about research protocols, including anonymity of individuals,
institutions and nations, where important,
though socially delicate research, is being conducted (Yeomans, N. 1965a, Vol 12, p. 129 - 130).
Thirdly, while Neville’s
evolving of the Laceweb and its nature as a social movement are researched, the
Laceweb networks themselves have not been researched. I have scant links to
these networks and I am not cleared to share information.
Fourthly, while the social
action being researched has drawn on East Asia,
I was privileged to
be mentored by Neville over a fourteen and a half year period from August 1985
to December, 1999. Neville arranged for me to engage in sustained action
research into (what I sense was) every aspect of his life work. I researched
and wrote this thesis with his blessing, encouragement, cooperation and
support. Further, I carried out this research in part so that Australians and
the World would know more about this man. With the issues facing the World,
Neville’s lifework is timely, practical, seminal and potent. This thesis
contributes to making his life work more accessible.
Chris Collingwood confirmed by email (Sept,
2004) that I first met Neville in August 1985 at a psychotherapy workshop
Neville was co-facilitating with Chris Collingwood and Nelson Pena Y Lillo in
Balmain, Sydney. At first, all I knew
about Neville was that he was a psychiatrist who had just come back from doing
an interesting workshop in the
The topic
of that Balmain workshop was the therapeutic potential of sensory submodality
change processes. It turned out that Neville had always been interested in the
functioning of the minute parts of the hypothalamic limbic region of the brain
in sensory submodality and cross-sensory processing and the therapeutic
potential of these understandings (Yeomans
1986).
(Examples of sensory submodalities are size, form and direction of internal
visual imagery. An example of cross-sensory processing is in hearing drumming
and then moving to the rhythm (auditory-kinaesthetic crossover)).
The
processes for therapeutically using sensory submodality processes that Neville
had just been studying in the United States are a part of Neuro-linguistic
Programming (NLP) evolved by Richard Bandler, John Grinder and others (Bandler
1985; Andreas and Andreas 1987). NLP is
the study of the structure of subjective experience (Dilts,
Grinder et al. 1980). Neville
also referred to NLP as ‘Natural Living Processes’ and ‘Natural Learning
Processes’ (Nov 1989, Nov 1993; June 1998).
Neville had
attended NLP workshops regularly overseas since their inception in the mid
Seventies - attending in
Neville kept
himself abreast of all of the innovations in NLP during the Eighties and
Nineties and continued to be an avid reader of neuro-psycho-biology till his
death. Neville made good use of the Internet in keeping abreast of
psycho-neurobiological research. During 1998 and 1999 he told me that he was
especially monitoring the small sensory sub-systems in the hypothalamic-limbic
region, and their implications and potential use in therapy.
During the Balmain workshop Neville singled
me out as a resonant person. At lunch on both days of the workshop we shared
life stories relating to working with groups and change processes. He
specifically engaged me on my academic and work experience. In July 1998
Neville told me that when he first talked with me at the workshop lunch on both
days in Balmain in 1985 he could see immediate and potentially useful ‘fit’
between his life work and many aspects of my background. By the end of the
lunch of the second day in Balmain, he knew I had a Social Science degree in
Sociology, and that my sociological theoretical perspectives and action
research (based in part on clinical sociology and sociology of knowledge) were
resonant with his own. He found out that my Behavioural Science Honours Degree
in Psychology entailed research in clinical psychology and that I had completed
postgraduate studies in neuro-psychology. He knew I had been eligible to do PhD
level research since 1981. He was also interested in the potential relevance
for his life work of my prior degree-level industry studies in actuarial and
financial services to become a Fellow of the Australian Insurance Institute by
examination. He also saw resonance in my Diploma level studies in Personnel
Management and Organizational Training and Development. I was for a time a member
of the Australian Institute of Personnel Management and the Australian
Institute of Training and Development. Neville delighted in my revelation that
I had been sacked from most of my jobs for provoking the system to change. At
the time I did not know that Neville specifically sought out people who were
living on the margin of society - those who, according to Neville, were
‘dysfunctionals laden with potential’. At that first meeting, I had no idea
that Neville was a constant networker and that he was checking me out as to how
I might fit and be interested in the social action he was engaged in. We
discussed my consulting work supporting chief executive officers of
multinational companies in resolving psychosocial issues between members of top
management, and my use of clinical sociology and psychosocial group process at
the senior executive level. I had been for ten years chairperson of the
Australian Insurance Institute – Life Branch Management Discussion Group. I found out later that he had seen ‘fit’ in
all aspects of my background including my security consulting work in
electronic article surveillance.
I had my training in counselling from Terry
O’Neill at the Student Counselling Unit at La Trobe University in the late
1970’s and was an on-call para-professional crisis counsellor in the La Trobe
University Student Counselling Centre for eighteen months. I found out shortly
after meeting Neville that Terry’s counselling was based largely upon his
voluntary work at Fraser House and the influence of Neville in the 1960’s. When I told Neville about Terry training me
in counselling, this further strengthened his interest in me as a potential
resource.
In December 1993 in Yungaburra, Queensland
Neville specifically broached my potential to research his lifework towards a
PhD. Key things for Neville were that I
was eligible to do a PhD and also, that I had experienced major trauma in my
life; I knew about trauma self-help from my personal experience. In that
December 1993 conversation, Neville went thoroughly into all my background
again, although the chatting was laid back. Little did I know then how my
entire blend of background ‘fitted’ his interests and foci. It seems that I was
potentially the person he had been looking for, for more than 20 years (Yeomans 1980a, p. 64 ; Yeomans 1980b). He tentatively suggested the possibility of
me doing a PhD on his life work a number of times in the following years.
By 1997, he was keen for me to get started as
he knew he was in real trouble with his health and that it was life
threatening. When I told him in July 1998 that I was starting a PhD on his life
he was elated. I could literally see his mind working. He was doing a final check
for fit. Then he said a big, ‘Yes! Your
background is perfect!’ I knew in large part this was because of the
combination of trauma in my life and my experience and abilities. As discussed
throughout this research, Neville had great faith in the dysfunctional fringe.
On hearing I was starting the PhD we immediately revisited our extensive
discussions during December 1993 where he ‘briefed me’ – now he started filling
in my understanding. While I had engaged in research since I had met Neville,
July 1998 was a very busy month of discussions to
get me started on disciplined seeking of data towards a PhD.
This thesis is about people connecting with
each other, and discovering and learning from and supporting each other. I will
share a few things that may support you in connecting with the pith and moment
of this research and how I came to be doing it. It is a warm December morning
in 1993 and Neville Yeomans and I are eating paw paw in Yungaburra. We are
surrounded by the lush greenness of the tropics of Far North Queensland,
In December 1993
Neville and I had sat at the bench in photo 5 below as we ate paw paw and
talked. Neville recalls becoming separated from his parents and being lost in
the hot arid
Photo
4.
The Mango Tree Outside of Neville’s Yungburra House - A photo I Took in
June 2001 a Month after Neville Died.
Photo 5. A photo I took in Neville’s Yungaburra House
on 30 May 2001.
Neville
takes me back in time with him in wandering away from his parents as a three
year old – this is Neville’s story taken from my file notes at the time:
Back there now I am absorbed in minutia -
looking at the little plants and pebbles. After a time my body is demanding my
attention away from the pebbles. I am becoming parched under the desert sun. My
mouth and lips are becoming very dry. My attention flits again to the pebbles.
Then everything begins to shimmer. Every direction seems the same. My legs
rapidly are going to jelly and the world begins to tilt all over the place as I
feel myself collapsing to the ground from heat exhaustion.
Neville is vividly relating his near-death
delirium.
Being a bright little three year-old, I know
about death and that I am about to die. I am desperately longing to live to
make the world a better place. In delirium, emotions are sweeping over me.
Awful dread mingles with immense love - and all this is reaching out for love and nurturing and all their possibilities.
I am seeing now a shimmering black giant coming towards me and feeling being
gently picked up. I melt into the giant’s gentleness - strong yet soft - and
presently I savour the cool fresh water that is being poured on my body and
gently touching my lips - beginning now to assuage my raging thirst. Still in
delirium, I feel being carried for a time and being now passed to a nurturing
Aboriginal woman by the Aboriginal tracker who had found me, and I feel truly
home again among the Aboriginal women and my yearning is being full-filled.
Photo 6 Neville lost in the bush
Neville went on to tell me that this gentle
nurturing supported his recovery from the delirium and trauma. Three-year-old Neville
in the care of those Aboriginal women had personal experience of Aboriginal
socio-medicine. He knew from his own experiencing of it that Aboriginal
socio-medicine is powerful. Neville had had conversations with psychiatrist
Richard Cawte and had read his writings about Aboriginal socio-medicine (Cawte 1974; Cawte 2001).
Australian Aboriginal socio-medicine entails a wide range of social
processes with a central aim of community social cohesion and wellbeing.
Aboriginal socio-medicine links the psychosocial with the psychobiological
through special forms of embodied social interaction. Neville experienced and
embodied this linking. Neville spoke of how, during the years of his childhood,
he constantly returned to his desert delirium experience as he was forming his
very big dream of doing things that would make the world profoundly different.
The dreaming evolved as an action quest towards enabling humanity in transitioning
to a humane new global epoch on Earth.
Neville said that from that traumatic
experience, what he was exploring and mulling over all the time as a child and
later as an adolescent, was how he could enable a sustainable transition to an
enduring new global epoch. He was talking of enabling a shift of the magnitude
of the one from the Feudal System to the Industrial System – though earth wide.
He read up on how that epochal transition occurred in the
Even on hearing Neville saying words like
these in 1993, it never occurred to me that that was what he was really attempting to do. It never
occurred to me that someone would actually take on such a task. It was too
immense. Subsequently, a number of people I interviewed about Neville all
confirmed the epochal focus of his social action. Margaret Cockett (April,
1999), his personal assistant at and after Fraser House, Stephanie Yeomans, his
sister-in-law (Jan, July, and Dec, 2002), and Stuart Hill (July 2000), a
professor of social ecology at University of Western Sydney, all said that
Neville had said similar things to the above in talking with them about the
emergence of his quest from his three year old childhood sociomedicine
experience. As well, Paul Wilson implies the same understanding of Neville’s
quest in his writing (1990, Ch. 6).
Neville went on to tell me a story that was similar to his being lost in the bush; it again involved trauma followed by recovery through Indigenous female nurturing. In 1943, Neville’s father co-purchased with his brother-in-law Jim Barnes, two adjacent properties totalling 1000 acres at North Richmond, one hour West of Sydney in NSW (Mulligan and Hill 2001, p. 191-202; Hill 2002a; Hill 2002b). In the next year when Neville was sixteen, a second defining episode occurred. Neville was out riding on the family’s pet horse Ginger on one of their properties with his Uncle Jim (Barnes) when they were caught in a grassfire that was being fanned by powerful winds. Neville told me (December, 1993) that Jim yelled to Neville to dismount and squeeze into a hollow in a tree trunk and cover himself to shield the radiant heat. The firestorm was coming towards them at phenomenal speed. The fire front was long. Jim on his horse could neither outflank it nor out-race it. Being too large to squeeze through the gap into the stump, Jim rode straight at the fire – attempting to ride through it. The horse went from under him, and Neville, watching from within the tree stump saw his Uncle burn to death. Amid the shock and horror was the dread of his own impending horrible death. Neville said that he slumped into traumatized delirium consumed with dread, laced with pervasive love similar to his experience when lost as a three year old. He described being on the edge of oblivion and again yearning for a better reality for all people. When found, physically safe, Neville was profoundly traumatized. Ginger his horse, though singed, survived.
Photo 7 P.A
Yeomans and Ginger the horse that Neville was riding during the fire - copied
with permission (Yeomans P.A. 1954, p121, Plate 4)
Circumstance created another similarity. At
age three it was the Aboriginal women who gave nurturing care. During the time
of this grass fire there happened to be an Islander women staying with the
Yeomans family as a housekeeper-support for Neville’s mother. The woman was an
Australian South Sea Islander - Kathleen Mussing[2].
It was in Kathleen’s nurturing care that Neville found enfolding love.
Neville attributed his healing from this
second trauma in the months following the fire, to the nurturing socio-medicine
of this housekeeper, Kathleen. In essence, this entailed love, care, nurturing
and affection as the central components of psychobiological healing. Neville
re-met Kathleen Mussing when she was old and dying and she didn’t recognize
him. Neville described (July 1999) that meeting as one of the saddest
experiences in his life, though permeated for him with immense love.
In the ensuing years up till the Yungaburra
1993 conversation, Neville had progressively involved me in aspects of his
quest. Even so, I knew very little. It was a bit at a time. I did not find his
‘On Global Reform’ paper on global epochal transition till after his death in
2000.
Neville had written a letter to the
International Journal of Therapeutic Communities in 1980 providing an overview
of his work (Yeomans 1980a; Yeomans 1980b; Hill 2002a; Hill 2002b). This short letter published in the
International Journal of Therapeutic Communities is reproduced in full below:
From
the Outback
Dear Sir,
Since A. W. Clark and I
produced the monograph ‘Fraser House’ in 1969, I have moved to private practice
in
‘Up North’ the therapeutic
community model has extended into humanitarian mutual help for social change.
Two of the small cities in this region have self-help houses based on Fraser
House. An Aboriginal Alcohol and Drug hostel is moving in the same direction,
as are other bodies.
These are facilitated by a
network called UN-Inma, the second word of which is aboriginal for Oneness.
Actually, aborigines have discussed offering one of the
The Director of the
Australian Institute of Criminology has the support of the United Nations
Secretary-General for the idea of an international island haven for otherwise
condemned political prisoners. Our proposal is an application and extension, in
which the Institute Director is ‘extremely interested’.
The main conditions sought
by the Indigenous group are that selected aborigines in Australian prisons also
be permitted to complete their sentences on such islands; and that therapeutic
self-management with conjugal rights be the administrative model.
One of our major next steps is to bring
together a psychosocial evaluative research team to monitor the development of
this regional community movement. Such may take some time as social scientists
are fairly uncommon in the area.
Some years ago, I arranged a cost-benefit
analysis of Fraser House, compared first with a traditional Admission unit in
another psychiatric hospital, and second with a newly constructed Admission
unit which some felt might be a pseudo therapeutic community.
Somewhat to my surprise Fraser House was not
only more effective but also cost less than the other two. The traditional unit
was next cost-effective and the ‘pseudo’ unit least. Unfortunately this report
was never publicly circulated. Until recently I was unable to locate a copy.
One has now been found and it seems I may soon have a manuscript (Yeomans 1980b).
This thesis revisits the above letter in
documenting the flow-on action from Fraser House. Note the reference in the
letter to bringing together:
a psychosocial evaluative research team to
monitor the development of this regional community movement. Such may take some
time as social scientists are fairly uncommon in the area.
Neville had been looking for someone like me
at least from 1980.
In November 1999, Neville asked whether I
would have the thesis finished by February 2000. He was very keen to read it,
though only when it was finished. When I told him it would not be finished by
then he said that was regrettable. Neville never did read any versions of my
thesis. In December 1999 there was inexplicably no reply on his phone for two
and a half weeks. Then one morning Neville’s daughter answered the phone and
said that Neville’s bladder cancer, which had been in remission, had rapidly
moved everywhere in his body, that he would die very soon and that they were
shifting him from hospital to his former wife (his second wife) Lien’s place in
Queensland. His daughter said he was so bad I would not be able to speak to him
again. This was devastating news. I rang the hospital for a status report and
was knocked further emotionally to be put directly though to Neville without
knowing this was about to happen. Neville spoke and sounded the best I had ever
found him. He was clear, calm, relaxed, poised and centred. He said:
Les, have you heard! The cancer’s gone
everywhere! I have just received a massive dose of morphine and I am going up
to be with Lien (his second Wife) and Quan (his son). I can’t help you any
more. Goodbye.
I said, ‘Goodbye.’ Those seconds were our
last chat. Then he hung up. Quan said in April 2000, ‘If Neville died this
instant it would be a mercy’.
He died about 4 weeks
later on 30 May 2000. Neville’s Obituary, written by a friend Peter Carroll was
read by Carroll at the funeral on 7 June 2000 at
This chapter has briefly
discussed the significance of the topic, outlined the nature of the research
and the research questions, and why they are important. It has explored how I
became involved in the project and the way my biography has led me to undertake
the research. The next chapter introduces Neville’s model for a 250-year
transition to a humane caring epoch.
Photo
8. A Yeomans family photo of Neville in his later years
[1] Fritz’s
paper ‘The Development of the Field of Clinical Sociology’ (2005) provides a
history of the field – Internet Source http://digilander.libero.it/cp47/clinica/friz.htm
(accessed 1 Aug 2005/0
[2] Kathleen Mussing was the sister of Faith
Bandler who was one of those responsible for the 1967 referendum asking people
to vote yes or no on whether they wanted the Australian constitution changed so
that Indigenous Australians had the same rights as other citizens (Chang,
2002). This was passed. Faith had support from